Surreal illustration of a surgeon's mind

Unlocking the Secrets of Surgical Expertise: How Surgeons Think Under Pressure

Author's portrait.
Elliot Brynn in Health & Wellness August 2025 • 4 min read.

"A deep dive into the cognitive strategies that separate expert surgeons from novices during critical moments in the operating room."


In the high-stakes world of surgery, patient outcomes are directly linked to the skills and performance of the surgical team. Understanding what makes a surgeon truly exceptional—their expertise—is not just academic; it’s a critical pursuit that can improve patient care and refine surgical training. But what exactly sets apart a seasoned surgeon from someone just beginning their journey?

While years of experience certainly play a role, surgical expertise goes far beyond simply accumulating time in the operating room. It encompasses a complex interplay of cognitive processes, situational awareness, and the ability to anticipate potential problems before they arise. Researchers have long sought to unravel these intricate factors, aiming to identify the key components that contribute to superior surgical performance.

A groundbreaking study published in The American Journal of Surgery sheds new light on this fascinating topic. By comparing the thought processes of expert and novice surgeons during a simulated critical event in laparoscopic cholecystectomy (gallbladder removal), researchers have uncovered valuable insights into the cognitive strategies that define surgical expertise. This article delves into the study's findings, exploring how cognition, mental imagery, and metacognition—thinking about thinking—impact a surgeon's ability to navigate challenging situations and ultimately, improve patient outcomes.

The Cognitive Toolkit of Surgical Expertise: What the Study Revealed

Surreal illustration of a surgeon's mind

The study, conducted across two medical centers, involved experienced surgeons and general surgery residents (considered novices in this context). Participants were shown a video recording of a complex laparoscopic cholecystectomy where a bleeding event occurred due to unexpected anatomy. Using a 'think aloud' protocol, surgeons verbalized their thoughts while watching the video, allowing researchers to analyze their cognitive processes in real-time.

Researchers meticulously transcribed and analyzed the verbal reports, categorizing each statement based on cognitive models of expertise. This detailed analysis revealed significant differences between the expert and novice groups in several key areas:

  • Deeper Comprehension: Experienced surgeons demonstrated a more thorough understanding of the operative field, quickly grasping the anatomical complexities and potential hazards.
  • Richer Mental Imagery: Experts were able to create vivid mental simulations of future events, anticipating potential complications and formulating contingency plans.
  • Enhanced Situational Awareness: Seasoned surgeons exhibited a heightened awareness of potentially dangerous situations, proactively identifying risks and taking steps to mitigate them.
  • Metacognitive Engagement: Experts spent more time reflecting on their own thought processes and the actions of the surgeon in the video, demonstrating a higher level of self-awareness and critical thinking.
In contrast, novice surgeons tended to focus on details of immediate local significance, sometimes missing the broader context and potential ramifications of their actions. They also exhibited less metacognitive activity, indicating a reduced ability to critically evaluate their own thinking and decision-making processes.

Implications for Surgical Training and Patient Safety

This research underscores the importance of cognitive skills development in surgical training. By explicitly teaching metacognitive strategies, encouraging deeper comprehension of the operative field, and fostering the ability to create rich mental imagery, surgical educators can help trainees develop the cognitive toolkit necessary for expert performance. Ultimately, this can lead to improved patient outcomes and a safer surgical environment.

About this Article -

This article was crafted using a human-AI hybrid and collaborative approach. AI assisted our team with initial drafting, research insights, identifying key questions, and image generation. Our human editors guided topic selection, defined the angle, structured the content, ensured factual accuracy and relevance, refined the tone, and conducted thorough editing to deliver helpful, high-quality information.See our About page for more information.

Everything You Need To Know

1

What exactly is surgical expertise?

Surgical expertise is not just about the years spent in the operating room. It involves a complex combination of cognitive processes, a keen awareness of the surgical environment, and the ability to foresee potential problems before they happen. This expertise allows surgeons to navigate complex situations effectively, ultimately improving patient outcomes. It requires a combination of comprehension, mental imagery skills, situational awareness and metacognitive engagement to effectively deal with any surgical situation.

2

What does cognition mean in the context of surgery and why is it so important?

Cognition in surgery refers to the mental processes a surgeon uses, such as comprehension, memory, and reasoning, to understand the surgical situation and make decisions. It's important because it allows surgeons to quickly grasp the complexities of the anatomy, anticipate potential hazards, and formulate appropriate responses to unexpected events. Expert surgeons use cognition to maintain a comprehensive understanding of the operative field, enabling them to make informed decisions and adapt to changing circumstances, ultimately improving patient safety.

3

Can you explain what mental imagery is in surgery and why it matters?

Mental imagery involves creating vivid mental simulations of future events during surgery. It's important because it allows surgeons to anticipate potential complications and develop contingency plans. By mentally rehearsing different scenarios, surgeons can prepare for unexpected challenges and react more effectively when they arise, leading to improved surgical outcomes and reduced risk for the patient.

4

What does situational awareness mean for a surgeon and why is it critical?

Situational awareness is the surgeon's understanding of what is happening around them in the operating room, including potential risks and hazards. It is crucial because it enables surgeons to proactively identify and mitigate dangers, ensuring patient safety. Expert surgeons exhibit heightened situational awareness, allowing them to anticipate problems before they escalate and take appropriate action to prevent adverse events.

5

What is metacognition in the context of surgical performance, and why does it matter?

Metacognition refers to the surgeon's ability to reflect on their own thought processes and actions during surgery. It involves thinking about thinking. It's important because it promotes self-awareness and critical thinking, allowing surgeons to evaluate their decision-making processes and identify areas for improvement. Surgeons with high metacognitive engagement are better equipped to learn from their experiences and refine their surgical techniques, leading to continuous professional development and improved patient outcomes.

Newsletter Subscribe

Subscribe to get the latest articles and insights directly in your inbox.