Healthcare professional unmasking stress and anxiety.

Unmasking Health Care's Hidden Crisis: How to Combat Unprofessional Behavior

"Pervasive bullying, discrimination, and harassment undermine health care, but effective solutions are within reach."


The healthcare system, meant to be a place of healing and care, is facing a silent epidemic: unprofessional behavior. Bullying, discrimination, and sexual harassment are widespread issues, creating a toxic environment for healthcare professionals.

Recent surveys paint a concerning picture. A 2016 Victorian Public Sector Commission study revealed that 25% of health agency staff experienced bullying. In 2015, nearly half (49%) of surveyed surgeons reported experiencing discrimination, bullying, harassment, or sexual harassment. These statistics are alarming, but likely underestimate the true prevalence due to underreporting and a lack of awareness regarding subtle forms of unprofessional conduct.

This article delves into the pervasive problem of unprofessional behavior in healthcare, exploring its impact on staff, patient safety, and organizational performance. We'll examine emerging evidence and practical interventions to cultivate a more respectful and professional healthcare environment.

The Ripple Effect: Understanding the Impact

Healthcare professional unmasking stress and anxiety.

Unprofessional behavior's impact extends far beyond individual discomfort. It creates a ripple effect, negatively impacting staff psychological wellbeing. High levels of stress, decreased teamwork, poor communication, and reduced concentration are commonly reported by healthcare professionals working in hostile environments.

The consequences extend to the quality of patient care. Studies show a direct link between unprofessional behavior and patient dissatisfaction, increased medical-legal risk, and significant financial costs for healthcare organizations. A disturbing study revealed that even low-level incivility can compromise patient safety, with teams subjected to rudeness during simulated medical scenarios performing significantly worse than those treated respectfully.

  • Compromised Patient Safety: Reduced information sharing, poor diagnostic performance, and delayed help-seeking behaviors directly threaten patient safety.
  • Financial Strain: Increased staff turnover, absenteeism, and potential lawsuits drain resources from already stretched healthcare systems.
  • Erosion of Professional Identity: Humiliation, belittling, and verbal abuse, often normalized in healthcare settings, negatively impact the development of professional identity, especially among students and trainees.
These factors highlight an urgent need for hospitals and healthcare organizations to commit towards creating professional work environment.

Charting a New Course: The Path Forward

Addressing unprofessional behavior requires a multi-faceted approach, beginning with acknowledging the problem and fostering open communication. While the 2016 Senate inquiry called for action, concrete guidance remains scarce.

Organizational professional accountability programs, like the Ethos program at St Vincent's Health Australia, offer promise by providing a safe channel for reporting and addressing unprofessional behavior. These programs rely on trained peer envoys who provide feedback about reported behavior to colleagues in an informal, non-punitive manner.

Ultimately, creating a safe and sustainable health system requires a fundamental cultural shift. This shift involves investing in research, rigorously evaluating interventions, and prioritizing respectful, collaborative teamwork. By embracing evidence-based approaches and fostering a culture of civility, the healthcare sector can ensure the wellbeing of its workforce and, most importantly, safeguard patient care.

About this Article -

This article was crafted using a human-AI hybrid and collaborative approach. AI assisted our team with initial drafting, research insights, identifying key questions, and image generation. Our human editors guided topic selection, defined the angle, structured the content, ensured factual accuracy and relevance, refined the tone, and conducted thorough editing to deliver helpful, high-quality information.See our About page for more information.

This article is based on research published under:

DOI-LINK: 10.5694/mja17.01261, Alternate LINK

Title: Endemic Unprofessional Behaviour In Health Care: The Mandate For A Change In Approach

Subject: General Medicine

Journal: Medical Journal of Australia

Publisher: AMPCo

Authors: Johanna Westbrook, Neroli Sunderland, Victoria Atkinson, Catherine Jones, Jeffrey Braithwaite

Published: 2018-11-01

Everything You Need To Know

1

What constitutes unprofessional behavior in healthcare, and why is it important?

Unprofessional behavior includes bullying, discrimination, and sexual harassment. It's important because it creates a toxic environment, negatively affecting staff well-being, patient safety, and organizational culture. It's a pervasive issue in healthcare, as evidenced by surveys such as the 2016 Victorian Public Sector Commission study, which revealed that 25% of health agency staff experienced bullying. The implications are significant, leading to decreased teamwork, poor communication, reduced concentration, and ultimately, a decline in the quality of patient care.

2

What are the key impacts of unprofessional behavior in healthcare?

The impact of unprofessional behavior extends to various areas. It leads to compromised patient safety due to reduced information sharing, poor diagnostic performance, and delayed help-seeking behaviors. It also creates financial strain through increased staff turnover, absenteeism, and potential lawsuits. Moreover, it erodes professional identity, particularly among students and trainees. Studies show a direct link between unprofessional behavior and patient dissatisfaction, increased medical-legal risk, and significant financial costs for healthcare organizations.

3

What are the key types of unprofessional behavior, such as bullying and harassment, and why are they significant?

Bullying and harassment are types of unprofessional behavior. Bullying involves repeated, unreasonable actions intended to intimidate, degrade, or undermine a person or group. Harassment includes any behavior that creates a hostile environment, often based on factors like gender or race. These behaviors are significant because they create a toxic work environment that affects all aspects of the organization. Such behaviors create high levels of stress, decreased teamwork, poor communication, and reduced concentration, leading to potential patient safety issues.

4

How does unprofessional behavior directly affect patient safety?

Patient safety can be directly compromised by unprofessional behavior in healthcare. Reduced information sharing, poor diagnostic performance, and delayed help-seeking behaviors are all direct consequences of unprofessional conduct. Studies, such as the one involving simulated medical scenarios, demonstrate that rudeness can significantly impair a team's performance, thereby threatening patient safety. The consequences of this also extend into the financial realm, including staff turnover and lawsuits. In effect, a hostile work environment puts patient safety at risk.

5

What steps can be taken to address unprofessional behavior in healthcare?

Addressing unprofessional behavior requires a multi-faceted approach. This begins with acknowledging the problem and fostering open communication. Acknowledging the issue is important because it sets the stage for implementing effective interventions. The 2016 Senate inquiry called for action, but specific guidance is still limited. This means that healthcare organizations must proactively develop and implement strategies to combat these behaviors, aiming to create a more respectful and professional environment. The long-term implication of such a shift is an improved work environment, improved patient outcomes and greater financial stability.

Newsletter Subscribe

Subscribe to get the latest articles and insights directly in your inbox.