Illustration of Carcinoid Crisis Mechanism

Unlocking Carcinoid Crisis: New Insights into Causes and Management

"A groundbreaking study challenges old assumptions about carcinoid crises, offering new paths for prevention and treatment, potentially improving outcomes for those at risk."


Carcinoid tumors, rare neuroendocrine tumors, release hormones like serotonin, leading to carcinoid syndrome. This syndrome causes flushing, diarrhea, and abdominal pain, significantly impacting quality of life. A more severe, acute complication is the carcinoid crisis, marked by sudden hemodynamic instability, posing a major threat during surgery.

Historically, massive hormone release was believed to trigger these crises. However, recent research challenges this long-standing belief. A prospective study appearing in "Surgery" offers new insights into what really causes a carcinoid crisis, potentially paving the way for better prevention and treatment strategies.

The study, led by Mary E. Condron, MD, and Rodney F. Pommier, MD, at Oregon Health & Science University, meticulously examined patients with carcinoid tumors undergoing abdominal operations. By monitoring hormone levels and cardiovascular function, the research team uncovered surprising truths that could redefine how we understand and manage this life-threatening event.

Challenging the Old: What Really Happens During a Carcinoid Crisis?

Illustration of Carcinoid Crisis Mechanism

The research team studied 46 patients with carcinoid tumors and liver metastases, all undergoing abdominal surgeries. They used advanced monitoring techniques, including echocardiography and pulmonary artery catheterization, to track real-time changes in cardiovascular function. Blood samples were collected to measure levels of serotonin, histamine, kallikrein, and bradykinin—hormones traditionally linked to carcinoid syndrome and crises.

Surprisingly, the study found no significant increase in hormone levels during a crisis. This contradicts the long-held theory of massive hormone release as the primary trigger. However, patients who experienced a crisis did have higher pre-operative serotonin levels, suggesting a possible link between baseline serotonin and crisis risk.

  • Hormone levels did not increase during a crisis, challenging traditional theories.
  • Higher pre-operative serotonin levels correlated with an increased risk of crisis.
  • Cardiac function remained normal during a crisis, but intracardiac hypovolemia was consistently observed.
  • Pulmonary artery pressure decreased during a crisis, suggesting vasodilation rather than constriction.
Further analysis indicated that the physiology of a carcinoid crisis resembles distributive shock, a condition where blood vessels dilate excessively, leading to reduced blood pressure and organ perfusion. This suggests that vasodilation, rather than a surge of hormones, may be the key driver behind the crisis.

Implications for Treatment: A New Direction

These findings shift the focus from blocking hormone release to managing vasodilation and maintaining blood pressure. The study also questions the effectiveness of octreotide, a drug traditionally used to prevent and treat carcinoid crises, since it targets hormone release rather than vasodilation. Future research should explore alternative treatments, such as vasopressors and fluids, to combat distributive shock during a crisis. Given the complex nature, expert opinions also suggest studying IL-6, because Serotonin is a known inducer of IL-6 expression.

About this Article -

This article was crafted using a human-AI hybrid and collaborative approach. AI assisted our team with initial drafting, research insights, identifying key questions, and image generation. Our human editors guided topic selection, defined the angle, structured the content, ensured factual accuracy and relevance, refined the tone, and conducted thorough editing to deliver helpful, high-quality information.See our About page for more information.

This article is based on research published under:

DOI-LINK: 10.1016/j.surg.2018.04.093, Alternate LINK

Title: A Prospective Study Of The Pathophysiology Of Carcinoid Crisis

Subject: Surgery

Journal: Surgery

Publisher: Elsevier BV

Authors: Mary E. Condron, Nora E. Jameson, Kristen E. Limbach, Ann E. Bingham, Valerie A. Sera, Ryan B. Anderson, Katie J. Schenning, Shaun Yockelson, Izumi Harukuni, Edward A. Kahl, Elizabeth Dewey, Suellen J. Pommier, Rodney F. Pommier

Published: 2019-01-01

Everything You Need To Know

1

What exactly is a carcinoid crisis, and why is it so dangerous?

Carcinoid crisis is a severe complication that can occur in individuals with carcinoid tumors. These tumors, which are rare neuroendocrine tumors, can release hormones like serotonin, leading to carcinoid syndrome. A carcinoid crisis is characterized by sudden hemodynamic instability, meaning a drastic change in blood pressure and circulation, which can be life-threatening, especially during surgery or other stressful events. The significance of understanding carcinoid crisis lies in its potential to cause organ damage and death if not promptly recognized and treated. Recognizing a crisis and understanding the underlying mechanisms are crucial for effective management and improved patient outcomes.

2

What were the surprising discoveries about hormone levels during a carcinoid crisis?

The study revealed that during a carcinoid crisis, hormone levels such as serotonin, histamine, kallikrein, and bradykinin do not significantly increase. This challenges the traditional belief that a surge of these hormones is the primary trigger for the crisis. However, it was observed that patients who experienced a crisis tended to have higher pre-operative serotonin levels, suggesting a potential link between baseline serotonin levels and the risk of a crisis. Additionally, the study found that cardiac function remained normal, but intracardiac hypovolemia (reduced blood volume within the heart) and decreased pulmonary artery pressure were consistently observed. These findings suggest that vasodilation, rather than hormone surges, may play a more significant role in the development of a carcinoid crisis.

3

What is distributive shock, and how is it related to a carcinoid crisis?

Distributive shock is a condition in which blood vessels dilate excessively, leading to reduced blood pressure and decreased blood flow to vital organs. The study indicated that the physiology of a carcinoid crisis closely resembles distributive shock. This means that during a crisis, the excessive vasodilation causes blood to pool in the periphery, leading to reduced blood return to the heart and decreased cardiac output. As a result, organs may not receive enough oxygen and nutrients, potentially leading to organ damage or failure. Recognizing that vasodilation is a key factor in carcinoid crisis has significant implications for treatment, as it suggests that therapies aimed at constricting blood vessels and maintaining blood pressure may be more effective than those targeting hormone release.

4

How effective is octreotide in treating a carcinoid crisis, given the latest research?

Octreotide is a medication traditionally used to prevent and treat carcinoid crises by targeting the release of hormones, particularly serotonin. However, the study's findings suggest that vasodilation, rather than hormone surges, may be the primary driver of a carcinoid crisis. This raises questions about the effectiveness of octreotide in managing crises since it does not directly address the vasodilation component. While octreotide may still have a role in managing the underlying carcinoid syndrome by reducing hormone production, the study suggests that alternative treatments, such as vasopressors and fluids, which combat vasodilation and maintain blood pressure, may be more beneficial in treating a carcinoid crisis.

5

What are the new recommended strategies for treating a carcinoid crisis, based on the latest findings?

Based on the new insights, the focus should shift from solely blocking hormone release to managing vasodilation and maintaining blood pressure during a carcinoid crisis. Potential treatment strategies include the use of vasopressors, which are medications that constrict blood vessels and raise blood pressure, and intravenous fluids to increase blood volume and improve cardiac output. These interventions aim to counteract the distributive shock-like state observed during a crisis. Additionally, further research is needed to explore other potential therapeutic targets, such as IL-6, as serotonin is a known inducer of IL-6 expression, potentially contributing to the inflammatory response during a crisis. A comprehensive approach that addresses both vasodilation and potential inflammatory factors may lead to more effective management of carcinoid crises.

Newsletter Subscribe

Subscribe to get the latest articles and insights directly in your inbox.