Surreal illustration of ancient crinoids with regenerating spines in a prehistoric ocean.

Unlocking Ancient Mysteries: How Crinoid Fossils Reveal Evolutionary Secrets

Author's portrait.
Samir D’Costa in Science & Nature August 2025 • 4 min read.

"Fossilized crinoid spines offer compelling evidence of predator-prey dynamics and adaptation over millions of years."


Imagine diving into an ancient ocean, teeming with life forms both familiar and strange. Among these, crinoids, often called 'sea lilies,' swayed gently in the currents. These marine animals, relatives of starfish and sea urchins, have a long and rich history, dating back hundreds of millions of years. While their soft bodies rarely fossilize, their skeletal remains, particularly their spines, offer a unique window into the past.

Fossilized crinoid spines are not just pretty rocks; they're time capsules containing valuable information about the ecosystems in which these creatures lived. In particular, the study of spine regeneration – the ability of a crinoid to regrow a damaged spine – provides direct evidence of predation attempts. The frequency and patterns of regeneration can tell us about the intensity of predation pressure and the evolutionary adaptations crinoids developed to survive in a dangerous world.

Recent research focusing on crinoid spines from the Upper Pennsylvanian period in eastern Ohio has uncovered some remarkable findings. These ancient spines exhibit evidence of repeated regeneration, suggesting that these crinoids were frequently targeted by predators. This discovery sheds new light on the predator-prey dynamics of the time and the evolutionary strategies crinoids employed to thrive amidst constant threats.

Repeated Regeneration: A Sign of the Times

Surreal illustration of ancient crinoids with regenerating spines in a prehistoric ocean.

The study, conducted by James R. Thomka and Donald B. Eddy, examined brachial spines (small, rod-like structures extending from the arms) of pirasocrinid crinoids from the Ames Member of the Glenshaw Formation. What makes these spines so special is the evidence of multiple regeneration events. In some specimens, size discontinuities along the length of the spine indicate that they had been broken and regrown not once, but multiple times during the crinoid's lifespan.

This repeated regeneration is a significant discovery. While regeneration in crinoids is a known phenomenon, previous studies have primarily focused on arm regeneration. Finding isolated ossicles (individual skeletal components) with clear evidence of multiple regeneration phases is rare. It suggests that these crinoids faced persistent threats throughout their lives.

What does this tell us?
  • High Predation Intensity: The frequency of regeneration suggests a high level of predation in the Upper Pennsylvanian seas of eastern Ohio.
  • Predator-Driven Evolution: The constant threat of predation may have been a driving force in the evolution of crinoid morphology, favoring traits that enhanced survival.
  • Ecosystem Dynamics: Understanding predator-prey relationships helps us reconstruct the complex web of life in ancient ecosystems.
  • Adaptation Strategies: Crinoids may have developed unique defense mechanisms, such as increased spinosity, to deter predators or minimize damage from attacks.
The researchers propose that frequent 'snipping' by predatory fishes is the most likely explanation for the observed pattern of repeated regeneration. Given the position of these spines on the elevated crown of the crinoid, they would have been vulnerable to attacks from fish swimming above. This suggests that these crinoids were a regular target for predators, even if they weren't the preferred meal.

More Than Just Fossils: A Glimpse into Evolutionary History

The study of crinoid spine regeneration provides a fascinating glimpse into the evolutionary history of these ancient creatures. By analyzing the patterns of breakage and regrowth, scientists can reconstruct the predator-prey dynamics of ancient ecosystems and gain a better understanding of the selective pressures that shaped the evolution of crinoid morphology. This research underscores the importance of studying fossils, not just as static objects, but as dynamic records of life's ongoing struggle for survival.

About this Article -

This article was crafted using a human-AI hybrid and collaborative approach. AI assisted our team with initial drafting, research insights, identifying key questions, and image generation. Our human editors guided topic selection, defined the angle, structured the content, ensured factual accuracy and relevance, refined the tone, and conducted thorough editing to deliver helpful, high-quality information.See our About page for more information.

This article is based on research published under:

DOI-LINK: 10.2110/palo.2018.058, Alternate LINK

Title: Repeated Regeneration Of Crinoid Spines In The Upper Pennsylvanian Of Eastern Ohio: Evidence Of Elevated Predation Intensity And Significance For Predator-Driven Evolution Of Crinoid Morphology

Subject: Paleontology

Journal: PALAIOS

Publisher: Society for Sedimentary Geology

Authors: James R. Thomka, Donald B. Eddy

Published: 2018-11-29

Everything You Need To Know

1

What are crinoids and why are their fossilized spines important for understanding ancient marine life?

Crinoids, often referred to as 'sea lilies,' are marine animals closely related to starfish and sea urchins. While their soft tissues rarely leave fossil traces, their skeletal remains, especially their spines, serve as invaluable records of ancient marine ecosystems. They have a long history going back hundreds of millions of years.

2

How do fossilized crinoid spines help scientists understand predator-prey relationships in prehistoric oceans?

Fossilized crinoid spines offer a wealth of information about prehistoric ecosystems. By examining spine regeneration patterns, scientists can deduce predation intensity. For instance, repeated regeneration suggests frequent predation attempts, shedding light on predator-prey dynamics. Furthermore, the research has direct bearing on understanding ecosystem dynamics.

3

What specific evidence did the study by James R. Thomka and Donald B. Eddy uncover about crinoid spine regeneration?

The study by James R. Thomka and Donald B. Eddy focused on brachial spines from pirasocrinid crinoids found in the Ames Member of the Glenshaw Formation. The distinguishing feature of these spines is the evidence of multiple regeneration events. Size discontinuities along the spine length indicate multiple instances of breakage and regrowth, showcasing the persistent threats faced by these crinoids throughout their lives.

4

What is the likely cause of the repeated regeneration observed in crinoid spines from the Upper Pennsylvanian period?

Frequent 'snipping' by predatory fishes is the most plausible explanation for the observed regeneration patterns in crinoid spines. The elevated position of these spines on the crinoid's crown made them vulnerable to attacks from fish swimming above, implying that crinoids were a regular target, even if not the preferred prey.

5

What can the study of crinoid spine regeneration tell us about the evolutionary history of these creatures?

The study of crinoid spine regeneration offers insights into the evolution of these ancient creatures and the reconstruction of predator-prey dynamics in ancient ecosystems. By analyzing breakage and regrowth patterns, scientists gain a better understanding of the selective pressures that shaped crinoid morphology. The study emphasizes the value of examining fossils as dynamic records of the continuous struggle for survival.

Newsletter Subscribe

Subscribe to get the latest articles and insights directly in your inbox.