Surreal illustration of a vast library symbolizing rediscovered sociological works.

Uncover Hidden Gems: Sociological Insights Beyond the Mainstream

"Dive into Andrew Abbott's curated collection of overlooked sociological works, revealing diverse perspectives and challenging conventional knowledge."


For 15 years, Andrew Abbott, as editor of the American Journal of Sociology, embarked on a unique endeavor: reviewing books of his own choosing, irrespective of publication dates or conventional sociological importance. This departure from the norm led to the rediscovery of works and authors who had been largely overlooked, now compiled in 'Varieties of Social Imagination' under the pseudonym "Barbara Celarent."

This collection showcases books and authors who often fall outside the scope of typical academic journals. Many are people of color, women, or scholars from countries outside the Western world, offering perspectives that challenge and enrich our understanding of society. The compilation spans a wide array of topics, from Herbert Marcuse to Frantz Fanon, alongside U.S. empirical sociology.

Abbott's selection transcends traditional academic boundaries, encompassing political tracts, party platforms, speeches, and poems, all contributing to the "social imagination." This approach echoes Howard Becker's 'Telling about Society,' which championed fiction, art, and theater as valid realms of sociological inquiry.

A Mindful Method: Uncovering the Unseen

Surreal illustration of a vast library symbolizing rediscovered sociological works.

Abbott's method of selecting books was driven by personal engagement, sparked by recommendations, intellectual adjacency, or even the physical presence of the books themselves. This haphazard approach allowed for a broadening of intellectual horizons, avoiding the pitfalls of systematization and representative sampling. Instead, the collection reflects the lived inclinations of Abbott, influenced by his experiences at Chicago and Oxford.

Through this exercise, Abbott immersed himself in a vast library, rereading and consulting related sources. When faced with linguistic barriers, he even undertook translating entire books, expanding his already impressive repertoire. The result is a kind of intellectual ethnography, offering insights into how a scholar thinks, reacts, and navigates the world of ideas.

Key aspects of Abbott's approach include:
  • Embracing diverse perspectives, from Marxism to Catholicism.
  • Searching for valuable insights across various movements and methods.
  • Bracketing personal biases to allow the value of each work to shine through.
  • Watchfulness against easy castigation that obscures intellectual complexity.
Abbott appreciates M. N. Srinivas's nuanced approach, contrasting it with "mechanical egalitarianism" (p. 142). He excuses Thoreau's "fog of misogyny" (p. 11) and acknowledges Heleieth Saffioti's earnest grappling with gender dynamics, even when it challenges conventional views. This willingness to engage with complex and sometimes contradictory ideas is a hallmark of Abbott's approach.

The Ever-Evolving Landscape of Sociology

Sociological positions are inevitably subject to obsolescence, not necessarily due to superior paradigms, but because ever-shifting contexts alter the meaning of what came before. As time reshapes our understanding, sociology finds itself in a state of transience. Abbott's curated collection reminds us of the arbitrary nature of our own understanding and the countless voices that have been muted or marginalized. By bringing these voices to light, Abbott encourages us to explore the diverse landscape of sociological thought and to continue making varieties of our own.

About this Article -

This article was crafted using a human-AI hybrid and collaborative approach. AI assisted our team with initial drafting, research insights, identifying key questions, and image generation. Our human editors guided topic selection, defined the angle, structured the content, ensured factual accuracy and relevance, refined the tone, and conducted thorough editing to deliver helpful, high-quality information.See our About page for more information.

This article is based on research published under:

DOI-LINK: 10.1177/0094306118805416, Alternate LINK

Title: Sociologies Missed And Found

Subject: Sociology and Political Science

Journal: Contemporary Sociology: A Journal of Reviews

Publisher: SAGE Publications

Authors: Harvey Molotch

Published: 2018-11-01

Everything You Need To Know

1

What is 'Varieties of Social Imagination' and how did Andrew Abbott curate the collection of overlooked sociological works?

Andrew Abbott's book, 'Varieties of Social Imagination,' compiles overlooked sociological works and authors that were often missed by mainstream academia. Abbott selected these works during his time as editor of the American Journal of Sociology, where he chose books to review based on personal engagement and intellectual curiosity, rather than traditional academic criteria. The collection includes diverse perspectives, such as those from people of color, women, and scholars from countries outside the Western world.

2

Can you describe the method Andrew Abbott used to select books for 'Varieties of Social Imagination'?

Abbott's selection process for 'Varieties of Social Imagination' involved a mindful method driven by personal engagement, sparked by recommendations, intellectual adjacency, and the physical presence of books. This haphazard approach allowed for broadening intellectual horizons, avoiding the pitfalls of systematization and representative sampling. Abbott also immersed himself in a vast library, rereading and consulting related sources, and even translating entire books to overcome linguistic barriers.

3

What are some examples of Andrew Abbott's approach to engaging with complex ideas within the sociological works in 'Varieties of Social Imagination'?

Abbott appreciates M. N. Srinivas's nuanced approach, contrasting it with "mechanical egalitarianism." He excuses Thoreau's "fog of misogyny" and acknowledges Heleieth Saffioti's earnest grappling with gender dynamics, even when it challenges conventional views. This willingness to engage with complex and sometimes contradictory ideas is a hallmark of Abbott's approach.

4

How does 'Varieties of Social Imagination' reflect the ever-evolving nature of sociological thought and its potential obsolescence?

The sociological landscape is always evolving and subject to obsolescence. This happens not necessarily because of superior paradigms, but because ever-shifting contexts alter the meaning of what came before. 'Varieties of Social Imagination' compilation reminds us of the arbitrary nature of our own understanding and the countless voices that have been muted or marginalized. By bringing these voices to light, Abbott encourages us to explore the diverse landscape of sociological thought and to continue making varieties of our own.

5

How does the concept of the 'social imagination' in 'Varieties of Social Imagination' connect with Howard Becker's ideas in 'Telling about Society'?

The idea of the 'social imagination,' as presented by 'Varieties of Social Imagination', aligns with Howard Becker's championing of non-traditional sources in 'Telling about Society'. Both advocate for including materials beyond academic journals, such as political tracts, party platforms, speeches, poems, fiction, art, and theater, as realms of sociological inquiry. This expansion allows for a more comprehensive understanding of society and culture by incorporating diverse voices and perspectives.

Newsletter Subscribe

Subscribe to get the latest articles and insights directly in your inbox.