A mother holding her baby, caught between her instincts and medical advice.

Tiny Tummies, Big Battles: When Feeding Advice Clashes with Mother's Instinct

"Explore the challenges new mothers face when scientific feeding guidelines for late preterm babies conflict with their own intuition and knowledge."


Becoming a new mother is filled with joy, but it also comes with challenges, especially when caring for a late preterm baby (LPB). While healthcare professionals aim to provide the best care, their feeding advice can sometimes clash with a mother’s own instincts and knowledge. This disconnect can lead to confusion, stress, and a feeling of powerlessness for new moms.

Existing healthcare frameworks emphasize patient-centered care, giving women choices and involving them in decisions. However, studies show that these principles aren't always consistently applied, particularly when dealing with preterm births. The medicalized approach to late preterm babies can overshadow a mother’s natural instincts and create barriers to a positive feeding experience.

This article dives into the experiences of women caring for late preterm babies, focusing on the feeding challenges they face. It highlights the tension between adhering to strict medical guidelines and trusting their own intuition, aiming to provide insights and support for mothers navigating this delicate balance.

The Feeding Frenzy: Strict Schedules vs. Mother's Intuition

A mother holding her baby, caught between her instincts and medical advice.

Research reveals that infant feeding for late preterm babies often becomes a highly structured process, dictated by strict schedules and prescribed amounts. Whether breastfeeding or formula-feeding, babies are often fed according to a rigid timetable, with supplementation enforced based on medical guidelines.

This approach can undermine a mother's confidence and ability to respond to her baby's cues. Instead of fostering instinctive care, it can create a sense of being controlled by external rules. As one study participant explained, it felt unnatural to be woken up by an alarm clock to feed her baby, disrupting her own sleep and sense of connection.

  • Alarm Clock Precision: Feedings are timed with alarm clock precision, disrupting natural rhythms.
  • Volume Control: Strict feeding guidelines and supplementation volumes are enforced by medical staff.
  • Powerless Mothers: Women often feel unable to influence feeding decisions, leading to a sense of disempowerment.
  • Suppressed Instincts: Rigid regimes do not facilitate instinctive mother-care or enable babies to demonstrate innate feeding behaviors.
Many mothers recognize that their babies are being overfed based on these strict guidelines. They intuitively understand their baby's needs, but feel pressure to adhere to medical advice, even when it seems counterproductive. Some women even reported facing resistance from staff when they tried to reduce top-ups to encourage breastfeeding.

Reclaiming Motherhood: Trusting Your Instincts

The current approach to caring for women and their late preterm babies often leads to feeding becoming a source of stress and anxiety, rather than a positive experience. Staff caring for women who have LPBs should focus on supporting women to trust their instincts and guide them in developing confidence in their ability to read their babies' cues, rather than focusing on strict regimes of feeding.

Individualized consideration of whether supplementation is required in the early days. These rigid routines and supplementation can make it harder for a mother to be successful. Keeping women and their babies together will facilitate understanding the behavior, and early and continued opportunities for skin-to-skin contact will assist staff in providing tailored support.

Ultimately, navigating the world of infant feeding requires a blend of professional guidance and personal intuition. By prioritizing a mother's instincts, healthcare providers can empower women to confidently care for their late preterm babies, creating a more positive and fulfilling experience for both mother and child. Further research into this model of care is needed, to establish whether it enhances women's experiences whilst also ensuring the safety and well-being of LPBs.

About this Article -

This article was crafted using a human-AI hybrid and collaborative approach. AI assisted our team with initial drafting, research insights, identifying key questions, and image generation. Our human editors guided topic selection, defined the angle, structured the content, ensured factual accuracy and relevance, refined the tone, and conducted thorough editing to deliver helpful, high-quality information.See our About page for more information.

This article is based on research published under:

DOI-LINK: 10.1016/j.midw.2018.11.001, Alternate LINK

Title: “His Tummy'S Only Tiny” – Scientific Feeding Advice Versus Women'S Knowledge. Women'S Experiences Of Feeding Their Late Preterm Babies

Subject: Maternity and Midwifery

Journal: Midwifery

Publisher: Elsevier BV

Authors: Luisa Cescutti-Butler, Ann Hemingway, Jaqui Hewitt-Taylor

Published: 2019-02-01

Everything You Need To Know

1

What are the main challenges new mothers face when feeding a late preterm baby (LPB)?

Caring for a late preterm baby (LPB) presents unique challenges for new mothers. These babies, born prematurely, often require specialized care, including feeding. However, the medicalized approach to their care can sometimes overshadow a mother’s natural instincts. The tension arises when strict medical guidelines, like those involving feeding schedules and prescribed volumes, clash with a mother's intuition about her baby's needs. This conflict can lead to stress and anxiety, making the feeding experience less positive.

2

How is the feeding of late preterm babies (LPBs) often managed?

The feeding of late preterm babies is often structured, sometimes dictated by strict schedules and prescribed amounts. Feedings are timed with alarm clock precision, disrupting natural rhythms. Healthcare professionals may enforce strict feeding guidelines and supplementation volumes. This approach can undermine a mother's confidence and ability to respond to her baby's cues. These regimes do not facilitate instinctive mother-care or enable babies to demonstrate innate feeding behaviors. Many mothers recognize that their babies are being overfed based on these strict guidelines. They intuitively understand their baby's needs, but feel pressure to adhere to medical advice, even when it seems counterproductive.

3

Why is a mother's intuition important in feeding a late preterm baby (LPB)?

A mother's intuition plays a crucial role in feeding her late preterm baby. It involves her ability to understand her baby's cues, recognize their needs, and respond accordingly. However, the article emphasizes the tension between adhering to strict medical guidelines and trusting their own intuition. The existing healthcare frameworks emphasize patient-centered care, giving women choices and involving them in decisions, but these principles aren't always consistently applied, particularly when dealing with preterm births. The medicalized approach can create barriers to a positive feeding experience.

4

What are the potential implications of conflicting feeding advice for mothers and their babies?

The implications of conflicting advice are significant. When mothers feel forced to follow strict medical guidelines that contradict their instincts, it can lead to several negative outcomes. It can undermine their confidence in their abilities, create stress and anxiety around feeding times, and disrupt the natural bonding process between mother and child. Feeling powerless in the face of medical advice can lead to a sense of disempowerment, making the feeding experience less enjoyable and potentially impacting the baby's development.

5

How can mothers navigate the challenges of conflicting advice and reclaim a positive feeding experience for their late preterm baby (LPB)?

To navigate the challenges, mothers should focus on trusting their instincts and finding ways to balance medical advice with their own understanding of their baby's needs. Healthcare professionals should support mothers in developing confidence in their ability to read their babies' cues. This can involve open communication, shared decision-making, and providing individualized care that respects both medical guidelines and the mother's intuition. Reclaiming Motherhood involves fostering a supportive environment that prioritizes the mother-child bond and promotes a positive feeding experience. It's about empowering mothers to feel confident and in control of their baby's care.

Newsletter Subscribe

Subscribe to get the latest articles and insights directly in your inbox.