Surreal illustration of a surgeon holding a heart-shaped tissue graft with Islamic geometric patterns.

Porcine-Free Procedures: A Muslim Patient's Guide to Tissue Engineering and Reconstructive Surgery

Samir D’Costa in Health & Wellness August 2025 • 4 min read.

"Navigating tissue engineering and reconstructive surgery within Islamic guidelines. Discover alternatives to porcine-derived biomaterials for Muslim patients seeking medical care."

Over the last three decades, tissue engineering and reconstructive surgery have revolutionized medical treatments, presenting novel therapeutic options. These advancements often involve biomaterials, used alone or in conjunction with cultured cellular products, to address the scarcity of autologous donor tissue and enhance healing across various surgical specialties, including abdominal, visceral, plastic, and cardiovascular surgery.

Many of these biomaterials are derived from porcine sources. Islam prohibits the consumption of pork or any of its by-products. This creates a unique challenge for Muslim patients, who account for a substantial portion of the global population (approximately 1.6 billion or 23 percent). Thus, it becomes crucial to thoroughly examine the implications of using porcine-derived tissue-engineered products in surgery.

This article addresses the permissibility of porcine-derived products in life-threatening conditions or severe diseases when non-porcine alternatives are unavailable. This distinction carries significant importance for the medical community and researchers in biotechnology and industry, prompting the exploration of alternative materials. This guide aims to provide clarity and support to Muslim patients navigating these complex medical decisions.

Understanding Islamic Bioethics: Core Principles for Medical Decisions

Surreal illustration of a surgeon holding a heart-shaped tissue graft with Islamic geometric patterns.

Islamic bioethical principles are deeply rooted in the teachings of the Qur'an and the traditions of Prophet Mohammad. In Islam, human beings are viewed as the pinnacle of creation (Qur'an [2:30]), entrusted with reason, responsibility, and the welfare of other creatures, the environment, and their health (Daar & al Khitamy, 2001). Illness isn't seen as a punishment but as a condition to be treated, encouraging Muslims to preserve their health and seek appropriate medical care (Daar & al Khitamy, 2001; Sachedina, 2005).

Four core concepts underpin Islamic bioethics:

Necessity prevails over prohibition: When faced with unavoidable circumstances, leniency is granted.
Prevention of harm: All possible measures should be taken to avert harm.
Lesser transgression: If a choice must be made, the lesser of two transgressions is preferred.
Societal interests: The well-being of society takes precedence over individual concerns.

The sanctity of life holds paramount importance, allowing restrictions to be waived for its preservation. Saving a life is a fundamental duty (Al-Sabki, 1991; Daar & al Khitamy, 2001; Qur'an [6:32]). Organ removal for transplantation, aimed at preserving life and alleviating suffering, is permitted under the principle that necessity overrides prohibition. This extends to homograft transplantation, supporting life through the replacement of failing organs. Resolution of bioethical dilemmas often involves consulting local Islamic authorities or scholars and seeking consensus on emerging medical technologies.

Making Informed Decisions: A Path Forward

Navigating medical treatments involving biomaterials requires careful consideration for Muslim patients. Understanding Islamic bioethical principles, exploring available alternatives, and engaging in open communication with medical professionals are essential steps. By prioritizing informed decision-making and respecting individual beliefs, patients and healthcare providers can work together to ensure the best possible outcomes within the framework of Islamic values.

About this Article -

This article was crafted using a human-AI hybrid and collaborative approach. AI assisted our team with initial drafting, research insights, identifying key questions, and image generation. Our human editors guided topic selection, defined the angle, structured the content, ensured factual accuracy and relevance, refined the tone, and conducted thorough editing to deliver helpful, high-quality information.See our About page for more information.

This article is based on research published under:

DOI-LINK: 10.1002/term.2788, Alternate LINK

Title: Porcine‐Derived Biomaterials In Tissue Engineering And Reconstructive Surgery: Considerations And Alternatives In Muslim Patients

Subject: Biomedical Engineering

Journal: Journal of Tissue Engineering and Regenerative Medicine

Publisher: Wiley

Authors: Faris Almarzouqi, Hans‐Oliver Rennekampff, Musab Almarzouki, Andreas Lambertz, Metesh Acharya, Christian Klink, Aron‐Frederik Popov, Norbert Pallua

Published: 2018-12-16

Everything You Need To Know

What are the key considerations for Muslim patients when undergoing tissue engineering or reconstructive surgery?

For Muslim patients, the primary consideration is the potential use of porcine-derived biomaterials. Islam prohibits the consumption of pork and its by-products, which necessitates exploring alternatives. Patients should understand Islamic bioethical principles, such as necessity prevailing over prohibition and the importance of preventing harm. Open communication with medical professionals is crucial to discuss available options and ensure treatments align with their beliefs. Consulting with local Islamic authorities can also provide guidance on specific medical technologies.

How do Islamic bioethical principles influence medical decisions, and what role does necessity play?

Islamic bioethics, rooted in the Qur'an and Prophet Mohammad's teachings, emphasize the preservation of life and health. Four core principles guide medical decisions: necessity prevails over prohibition, prevention of harm, the lesser of two transgressions, and societal interests. When faced with life-threatening conditions or severe diseases, the principle of necessity allows for the use of otherwise prohibited materials, such as porcine-derived products if non-porcine alternatives are unavailable. Saving a life is a fundamental duty, and restrictions can be waived to achieve this goal.

What are the specific challenges faced by Muslim patients in tissue engineering and reconstructive surgery, and how can they be addressed?

The main challenge is the potential use of porcine-derived biomaterials, which are commonly used in these procedures. This conflicts with Islamic dietary laws. To address this, patients must understand Islamic bioethical principles, explore non-porcine alternatives, and communicate openly with healthcare providers. Alternatives may include autologous donor tissue or other biomaterials. Seeking guidance from local Islamic scholars can provide clarity on the permissibility of specific treatments. Informed decision-making and respecting individual beliefs are essential for navigating these complex medical situations.

Can you explain the concept of 'necessity prevails over prohibition' in the context of medical treatments for Muslims?

The principle 'necessity prevails over prohibition' is a cornerstone of Islamic bioethics. It means that when faced with unavoidable circumstances, such as life-threatening situations or severe diseases, leniency is granted. If a treatment requires a material or procedure normally prohibited, like the use of porcine-derived biomaterials, it may be permissible if no suitable alternatives exist. This principle prioritizes the preservation of life and health, recognizing that these take precedence over strict adherence to prohibitions in critical medical scenarios. The decision should be made in consultation with medical professionals and, where possible, with guidance from Islamic scholars.

What role does communication and seeking guidance play for Muslim patients undergoing medical procedures involving biomaterials?

Open communication with medical professionals and seeking guidance from Islamic scholars are crucial for Muslim patients. Patients should discuss the biomaterials used in their procedures, exploring if any porcine-derived materials are involved. Understanding the specific composition of the biomaterials is important. Consulting local Islamic authorities provides clarity based on Islamic jurisprudence and the specific medical context. This collaborative approach allows patients to make informed decisions aligned with their beliefs and ensures the best possible outcomes within the framework of Islamic values. It also helps in navigating the complexities of medical treatments and upholding Islamic principles.