Lucerne moth evading bat echolocation through erratic flight.

Moth vs. Bat: How Lucerne Moths Use Erratic Flight to Dodge Echolocation

"New research reveals the surprising escape tactics of lucerne moths, highlighting their ability to evade bats with unpredictable flight patterns."


The nighttime world is a battleground, especially for insects facing predators that hunt by sound. Bats, masters of echolocation, send out ultrasonic pulses to navigate and find their prey. In response, many moths have developed ultrasound-sensitive hearing to detect these signals and evade capture. The stakes are high: survival depends on outsmarting these aerial hunters.

Typically, when a moth hears the faint cries of a distant bat, it might make a slight turn to steer clear. But when a bat gets closer, emitting louder and more frequent pulses, moths often resort to erratic, unpredictable flight. Some even cease flying altogether, diving to the ground in a last-ditch attempt to escape. But not all moths follow this pattern.

A recent study focuses on the lucerne moth (Nomophila nearctica) and its unique evasion strategy. Unlike many moths, the lucerne moth rarely dives in response to bat echolocation. Instead, it relies on early and erratic flight maneuvers, regardless of how close the bat is. This approach challenges traditional understanding of moth behavior and highlights the diversity of survival tactics in the insect world.

Lucerne Moths: Early Dodging Experts

Lucerne moth evading bat echolocation through erratic flight.

Researchers at the University of Toronto Scarborough investigated how lucerne moths respond to simulated bat echolocation calls. They found that these moths consistently turned away or flew erratically when they detected ultrasonic pulses above a certain intensity, no matter the specific pattern or frequency of the calls. This indicates that lucerne moths prioritize early action over last-minute desperate measures.

The team synthesized six different types of ultrasonic pulses, mimicking the stages of a bat's hunting sequence—from the initial search to the final approach. These pulses were broadcast at varying sound levels to tethered, flying lucerne moths. The moths' reactions were then recorded and analyzed.

  • No Response: The moth continued flying without any noticeable change in direction or flight pattern.
  • Turning-Away Response: The moth altered its course to fly away from the source of the ultrasonic sound.
  • Erratic Response: The moth exhibited unpredictable flight patterns, such as looping, zigzagging, or spiraling.
The results showed that lucerne moths initiated evasive maneuvers, especially erratic flight, when the sound reached 60 dB SPL (sound pressure level). This level suggests that the moths were reacting to bats at a distance, focusing on evasion well before the bat was in striking range. Interestingly, the moths never exhibited flight cessation or passive dives, which are common in other moth species as a final escape attempt.

Why Early Evasion Works

This early escape strategy might be particularly effective because bats can track and catch erratically flying moths. By initiating unpredictable flight early, the lucerne moth increases its chances of avoiding capture, blending into cluttered environments, or simply exhausting the bat's pursuit.

While diving might seem like a foolproof last resort, it’s risky. Bats are adept at catching diving moths, making early, evasive maneuvers a more reliable survival tactic for lucerne moths. This behavior is advantageous, particularly because these moths often fly close to the ground, where vegetation provides additional cover.

The lucerne moth's strategy highlights the complexity of predator-prey relationships and the diverse ways in which animals adapt to survive. Further research into other moth species could reveal even more unique strategies in the ongoing battle between bats and their insect prey.

About this Article -

This article was crafted using a human-AI hybrid and collaborative approach. AI assisted our team with initial drafting, research insights, identifying key questions, and image generation. Our human editors guided topic selection, defined the angle, structured the content, ensured factual accuracy and relevance, refined the tone, and conducted thorough editing to deliver helpful, high-quality information.See our About page for more information.

This article is based on research published under:

DOI-LINK: 10.1371/journal.pone.0202679, Alternate LINK

Title: Early Erratic Flight Response Of The Lucerne Moth To The Quiet Echolocation Calls Of Distant Bats

Subject: Multidisciplinary

Journal: PLOS ONE

Publisher: Public Library of Science (PLoS)

Authors: Ryo Nakano, Andrew C. Mason

Published: 2018-08-20

Everything You Need To Know

1

What is the main evasion strategy used by the lucerne moth?

The lucerne moth's unique evasion strategy revolves around early and erratic flight maneuvers to avoid capture. When the lucerne moth detects ultrasonic pulses from the bat, it consistently turns away or flies erratically, regardless of the bat's proximity. This approach contrasts with other moths that might dive or cease flying as a last resort. This early erratic flight is triggered when the sound reaches 60 dB SPL, indicating the moth is reacting to bats from a distance, and prioritizing evasion before the bat gets too close.

2

What role does echolocation play in this context?

Echolocation is a crucial sensory mechanism used by bats to navigate and hunt in the dark. Bats emit ultrasonic pulses, and then use the returning echoes to perceive their surroundings and locate prey. The lucerne moth's survival hinges on its ability to detect and respond to these echolocation signals. The moth uses its ability to detect these signals and alter its flight patterns to avoid the bat.

3

Why is the lucerne moth's behavior significant?

The significance of the lucerne moth's behavior lies in its early and erratic flight tactics. Unlike many other moth species, the lucerne moth does not dive or cease flying. This strategy is effective because bats can track and catch erratically flying moths. By initiating unpredictable flight early, the lucerne moth increases its chances of avoiding capture. The early and erratic responses enhance the lucerne moth's survival.

4

How did the researchers investigate the lucerne moth's behavior?

The University of Toronto Scarborough researchers mimicked a bat's hunting sequence using synthesized ultrasonic pulses, which they broadcast at varying sound levels to tethered, flying lucerne moths. They recorded the moths' reactions to different types of pulses, ranging from initial search to final approach. The pulses were broadcast at varying sound levels. The researchers then analyzed these reactions to understand how lucerne moths respond to simulated bat echolocation calls, helping to understand the moth's survival tactics.

5

What are the implications of the lucerne moth's erratic flight strategy?

The implications of the lucerne moth's erratic flight lie in how it challenges the traditional understanding of moth behavior and highlights the diversity of survival tactics in the insect world. This early escape strategy might be particularly effective because bats can track and catch erratically flying moths. By initiating unpredictable flight early, the lucerne moth increases its chances of avoiding capture. This behavior also indicates how important early detection and response are for survival.

Newsletter Subscribe

Subscribe to get the latest articles and insights directly in your inbox.