Symbolic image representing job security, law, and the modern economy.

Job Security SOS: Can a Century-Old Law Save Us?

Rhea Morgan in Law & Justice August 2025 • 4 min read.

"Unlock the secrets of the Wagner Act and discover if it holds the key to resolving today's precarious job market for workers of all ages."

The modern economy presents a paradox. We live in a time of unprecedented technological advancement, yet job security feels increasingly elusive. Economic contractions hit workers hard, leaving many vulnerable. While economic growth is generally seen as a remedy, it doesn't always guarantee stability for everyone. The question is, how can we create a more resilient job market that protects workers during economic storms?

This article delves into that very question, examining whether a piece of legislation from the past – the Wagner Act, also known as the National Labor Relations Act (NLRA) – can offer solutions for today's job market. This landmark law, born out of the New Deal era, aimed to empower workers and promote collective bargaining. But can its principles be applied to address the unique challenges of the 21st century?

We'll unpack the core issues surrounding worker vulnerability during economic downturns and explore how the Wagner Act's emphasis on collective bargaining could provide a pathway to greater job security and economic stability. Is it possible that a law from nearly a century ago holds the key to resolving today's job-security crisis?

Why Are Workers More Vulnerable During Economic Downturns?

Symbolic image representing job security, law, and the modern economy.

When the economy takes a hit, businesses face intense pressure to cut costs. While they might always be looking to save money, downturns amplify the need to reduce expenses, fast. Labor costs, being more flexible than fixed assets, often become the primary target.

Companies might choose between laying off employees or reducing wages and benefits. Layoffs, while painful, can seem like a quicker solution than navigating the complexities of wage reductions. Managers also worry about the impact of wage cuts on employee morale and productivity.

Cutting Labor Costs is Easier: It is more quicker to decrease labour cost than cutting other cost.
Layoffs vs. Wage Cuts: Layoffs are often seen as the easier option.
Impact on Morale: Cutting wages also hurts morale.

One manager, as quoted in the original research, noted that laying off an employee, even to replace them with someone at a lower wage, can be easier than dealing with the fallout from reducing an existing employee's pay. This highlights the difficult choices companies face and the human impact of these decisions.

A Path Forward: Empowering Workers for a More Secure Future

Promoting meaningful and timely discussions between employers and employees is vital for creating allocatively efficient solutions to the problems faced by struggling firms. Workers often possess valuable insights into shop operations and can offer cost-saving ideas that management might overlook. By giving workers a voice and a chance to participate in decision-making, we can create a more equitable and resilient job market that values both autonomy and dignity.

About this Article -

This article was crafted using a human-AI hybrid and collaborative approach. AI assisted our team with initial drafting, research insights, identifying key questions, and image generation. Our human editors guided topic selection, defined the angle, structured the content, ensured factual accuracy and relevance, refined the tone, and conducted thorough editing to deliver helpful, high-quality information.See our About page for more information.

This article is based on research published under:

DOI-LINK: 10.2139/ssrn.2051104, Alternate LINK

Title: The Relevance Of The Wagner Act For Resolving Today'S Job-Security Crisis

Journal: SSRN Electronic Journal

Publisher: Elsevier BV

Authors: Anne Marie Lofaso

Published: 2012-01-01

Everything You Need To Know

What is the Wagner Act, and what was its original purpose?

The Wagner Act, officially known as the National Labor Relations Act (NLRA), is a landmark piece of legislation from the New Deal era that seeks to empower workers by promoting collective bargaining. It was designed to address imbalances in bargaining power between employers and employees, aiming to foster a more equitable relationship. Although the text only mentions its potential in solving the job security crisis, the Act also covers workers' rights to organize, bargain collectively, and engage in protected, concerted activities.

Why are workers often more vulnerable during economic downturns, and how does the Wagner Act address this?

During economic downturns, companies often prioritize cutting costs, and labor costs are frequently targeted because they are perceived as more flexible than fixed assets. Layoffs are often seen as a quicker and simpler solution compared to reducing wages or benefits, despite the potential negative impact on employee morale and productivity. The Wagner Act attempts to address this by providing a framework for workers to collectively bargain for better protections and alternative solutions during such times.

How does collective bargaining, as promoted by the Wagner Act, contribute to job security and economic stability?

Collective bargaining, as promoted by the Wagner Act, enables workers to negotiate with employers as a group, rather than individually. This process aims to create a more equitable balance of power, allowing workers to secure better wages, benefits, and working conditions. It can also provide a platform for workers to voice their concerns and offer solutions to improve the efficiency and stability of their workplaces. The text highlights that workers often possess valuable insights into shop operations and can offer cost-saving ideas that management might overlook.

What are some limitations of relying solely on the Wagner Act to address modern job-security challenges?

While the Wagner Act primarily focuses on collective bargaining, it does not directly address issues such as automation, globalization, or the rise of the gig economy, which also contribute to job insecurity. Furthermore, the Wagner Act may not cover all types of workers, such as independent contractors or those in certain industries. To fully address the modern job-security crisis, a more comprehensive approach may be needed, combining the principles of the Wagner Act with policies that address these emerging challenges and protect a broader range of workers.

What are the potential benefits of empowering workers through legislation like the Wagner Act, beyond just job security?

Empowering workers through initiatives like the Wagner Act can lead to a more resilient and equitable job market. By giving workers a voice in decision-making processes, companies can tap into valuable insights and create solutions that benefit both employees and the organization. This approach promotes not only economic stability but also worker autonomy and dignity, fostering a more engaged and productive workforce. Furthermore, the NLRA ensures that employees can freely associate and collectively bargain without fear of employer retaliation.