Diverse professionals collaborating around a holographic table, symbolizing knowledge sharing and teamwork.

Is Knowledge Hoarding a Myth? Unveiling the Truth Behind Workplace Collaboration

"Explore the surprising findings that challenge the common belief about knowledge hoarding and reveal the real drivers of information sharing in the modern workplace."


For years, organizations have operated under the assumption that employees instinctively hoard knowledge, viewing it as a personal asset. This belief has fueled countless management strategies aimed at extracting and disseminating this so-called hidden knowledge. However, emerging research is challenging this deep-seated assumption, suggesting that knowledge hoarding may not be as prevalent—or as simple—as we once thought.

This article delves into a groundbreaking study that questions the very foundation of knowledge hoarding. By examining the behaviors and perceptions of IT service professionals, the research reveals a more nuanced reality of workplace collaboration. Are employees truly resistant to sharing their expertise, or are there other factors at play that influence their willingness to contribute to the collective knowledge pool?

As we navigate the complexities of modern work environments, understanding the true nature of knowledge sharing is crucial for fostering innovation, improving productivity, and building a culture of trust and collaboration. Join us as we debunk the myths surrounding knowledge hoarding and explore the path toward a more enlightened approach to workplace collaboration.

Challenging the Notion: Is Knowledge Hoarding Real?

Diverse professionals collaborating around a holographic table, symbolizing knowledge sharing and teamwork.

Conventional wisdom paints a picture of the knowledge hoarder as a selfish individual, clinging to information for personal gain or job security. However, a recent study focusing on IT service professionals casts doubt on this stereotype. The research reveals that these workers, often assumed to be knowledge hoarders, actively engage in sharing their expertise and insights with colleagues.

The study employed qualitative research methods, including interviews and observations, to gain a deeper understanding of how IT service professionals interact with knowledge in their daily routines. The findings challenge the notion that these workers are inherently resistant to sharing their expertise. Instead, the research highlights a culture of collaboration, where individuals readily assist each other and contribute to the collective problem-solving process.

  • Collaboration Ethic: Across all sites, the data revealed a strong ethic of collaboration, with IT professionals frequently drawing upon the experiential knowledge of colleagues.
  • Spontaneous Assistance: Workers often listened in on their colleagues' conversations and offered knowledgeable contributions without being asked.
  • Instant Messaging for Knowledge Sharing: The use of instant messaging software facilitated quick and easy knowledge sharing, allowing technicians to tap into each other's expertise without disrupting their workflow.
These observations suggest that the assumption of widespread knowledge hoarding may be unfounded. The IT professionals in the study demonstrated a willingness to share their knowledge and collaborate with colleagues, contradicting the stereotype of the selfish hoarder.

Reimagining Knowledge Sharing in the Workplace

The research presented in this article challenges long-held assumptions about knowledge hoarding and offers a new perspective on workplace collaboration. By debunking the myth of the selfish hoarder, organizations can focus on fostering a culture of trust, open communication, and mutual support. Encouraging spontaneous knowledge sharing, providing accessible tools for collaboration, and recognizing the value of collective expertise can pave the way for a more innovative and productive work environment. Ultimately, the key lies in understanding the real drivers of knowledge sharing and creating a workplace where everyone feels empowered to contribute their unique skills and insights.

About this Article -

This article was crafted using a human-AI hybrid and collaborative approach. AI assisted our team with initial drafting, research insights, identifying key questions, and image generation. Our human editors guided topic selection, defined the angle, structured the content, ensured factual accuracy and relevance, refined the tone, and conducted thorough editing to deliver helpful, high-quality information.See our About page for more information.

This article is based on research published under:

DOI-LINK: 10.1108/jkm-04-2017-0146, Alternate LINK

Title: The Rhetoric Of “Knowledge Hoarding”: A Research-Based Critique

Subject: Management of Technology and Innovation

Journal: Journal of Knowledge Management

Publisher: Emerald

Authors: Clive Trusson, Donald Hislop, Neil F. Doherty

Published: 2017-10-09

Everything You Need To Know

1

Is "knowledge hoarding" as widespread as commonly believed in today's workplaces?

The assumption that employees instinctively hoard knowledge is being challenged. Research focusing on IT service professionals indicates a culture of collaboration and willingness to share expertise, suggesting that "knowledge hoarding" may not be as prevalent as once thought. This reveals a more nuanced reality of workplace collaboration.

2

What factors encourage IT service professionals to share their knowledge with colleagues?

Several factors contribute to IT service professionals' willingness to share knowledge. A strong "collaboration ethic", where individuals frequently draw upon the experiential knowledge of colleagues, "spontaneous assistance", where workers offer knowledgeable contributions unasked, and the use of "instant messaging" for quick knowledge sharing all play a role in fostering knowledge sharing.

3

How does instant messaging facilitate knowledge sharing among IT service professionals, and why is this significant?

"Instant messaging" allows technicians to tap into each other's expertise without disrupting their workflow, facilitating quick and easy knowledge sharing. This is significant because it enables real-time problem-solving and collaboration, contributing to a more productive and innovative work environment. It exemplifies how accessible tools can support a culture of knowledge exchange.

4

If "knowledge hoarding" isn't the primary issue, what should organizations focus on to improve workplace collaboration?

Instead of focusing on extracting 'hidden knowledge' based on the assumption of "knowledge hoarding", organizations should focus on fostering a culture of trust, open communication, and mutual support. Encouraging "spontaneous knowledge sharing", providing accessible tools for collaboration like instant messaging, and recognizing the value of collective expertise are key strategies. Ultimately the focus must be on the real drivers of knowledge sharing.

5

What are the broader implications of debunking the myth of widespread "knowledge hoarding" for management strategies and organizational culture?

Debunking the myth of widespread "knowledge hoarding" implies a shift in management strategies from extraction of knowledge to promoting organic knowledge sharing. It suggests that organizational culture should be built on trust and open communication, encouraging employees to share insights freely. It enables the creation of more collaborative, innovative, and productive work environments. Furthermore, recognizing that the assumption of "knowledge hoarding" is flawed leads to different approaches when dealing with issues of poor knowledge sharing or lack of collaboration.

Newsletter Subscribe

Subscribe to get the latest articles and insights directly in your inbox.