Head Lice Treatment: Why Cocamide DEA Lotion Falls Short
"A candid look at cocamide diethanolamine lotion's limited success in eliminating head lice, based on laboratory and clinical trials."
Head lice infestations are a common nuisance, particularly among school-aged children. While numerous treatments are available, the effectiveness of some products has been challenged by insecticide resistance. This situation has prompted the search for alternative solutions, including treatments based on surfactants, which work by disrupting the lice's outer layer, leading to dehydration.
One such surfactant-based treatment is cocamide diethanolamine (cocamide DEA) lotion. Cocamide DEA is a chemical commonly found in shampoos, valued for its ability to create foam and remove oils. The idea behind its use as a lice treatment is that it can dissolve the waterproofing lipids protecting the louse, ultimately causing dehydration and death.
However, a study published in PeerJ investigated the actual effectiveness of cocamide DEA lotion in eliminating head lice. The study combined laboratory tests with two clinical trials to assess how well the lotion performed in real-world conditions. The results, as we will explore, revealed the limitations of this approach.
How Was the Cocamide DEA Lotion Tested?
The study employed a multi-stage approach, starting with in vitro (laboratory) tests to understand how cocamide DEA affected lice and their eggs. These tests mimicked real-life application, helping researchers predict how the lotion would perform on actual infestations. The laboratory tests were followed by two randomized, controlled clinical trials within communities.
- Clinical Study 1: Participants received a single application of 10% cocamide DEA lotion for 60 minutes, followed by shampooing. Some were treated with 1% permethrin creme rinse, a common insecticide.
- Clinical Study 2: Compared two regimens of 10% cocamide DEA lotion: a single overnight application versus two 2-hour applications one week apart, each followed by shampooing. Hair drying was used to concentrate the lotion.
What Does This Mean for Head Lice Treatment?
While cocamide DEA showed some initial promise in laboratory tests, the clinical trials revealed its limitations. The lotion, even when concentrated through hair drying, did not effectively eliminate head lice infestations in most cases. This suggests that relying solely on cocamide DEA as an active ingredient may not be a sufficient solution for treating head lice.