Dimethyl Fumarate transforming into a map of Europe

Fumaric Acid Esters: The Psoriasis Treatment Becoming a European Standard

"From Patient Discovery to European Approval: How Fumaric Acid Esters are Revolutionizing Psoriasis and Multiple Sclerosis Treatment."


The story of fumaric acid esters in medicine is extraordinary. Originating from a patient's insight, developed by Swiss pharmacists, clinically tested by German dermatologists, and initially approved only in Germany, Fumaderm® achieved a market share of up to 60% among conventional systemic therapies. This medication holds a distinctive position in the world of dermatology.

However, the history of fumaric acid esters is marked by unusual circumstances. The composition of Fumaderm®, including dimethyl fumarate and three ethyl hydrogen fumarate salts, was never scientifically justified. To this day, the rationale behind this specific mixture remains unknown. Furthermore, the approval of Fumaderm® in 1994 was primarily based on data from a single double-blind, randomized, placebo-controlled study conducted by Peter Altmeyer in Bochum, involving only 100 patients over 16 weeks.

Despite these unusual beginnings, Fumaderm®'s success grew, becoming a leading systemic treatment for psoriasis. This success did not go unnoticed by dermatologists in other European countries. While the Netherlands had long been producing similar formulations in hospital pharmacies, the UK and Ireland had special arrangements allowing certain centers to prescribe imported Fumaderm®. Even in these countries, it became a frequently used systemic therapy for psoriasis.

From Fumaderm® to Tecfidera®: Overcoming Regulatory Hurdles

Dimethyl Fumarate transforming into a map of Europe

The irrational mixture of fumaric acid esters in Fumaderm® hindered its approval outside of Germany. Consequently, the Swiss company Fumapharm AG developed FAG-201, a new drug containing only the active ingredient dimethyl fumarate (DMF). This was intended for the European and international markets. Following an initial Phase II study of FAG-201 in psoriasis patients in Poland, Fumapharm partnered with the US firm Biogen.

Together, they conducted a European multi-center study with BG-12 (later known as Tecfidera®) in Germany, Sweden, Denmark, France, and the Netherlands. This study revealed that BG-12 had comparable efficacy to Fumaderm® but with significantly fewer gastrointestinal side effects, thanks to a new formulation using DMF-containing microtablets in a gastric acid-resistant capsule.

  • Key Development: BG-12, containing only Dimethyl Fumarate (DMF), showed fewer gastrointestinal side effects.
  • Psoriasis Focus Shift: Biogen acquired Fumapharm in 2006, halting the psoriasis program and focusing BG-12 on multiple sclerosis.
  • Regulatory Approval: The FDA and EMA approved BG-12 (Tecfidera®) for multiple sclerosis treatment.
In a controversial move, regulatory bodies granted DMF in Tecfidera® the status of a "new chemical entity," despite being identical to the DMF in Fumaderm®. This prevents direct comparison of data between Fumaderm® and Tecfidera® for regulatory purposes. One potential reason for this decision is the price difference: Tecfidera® costs 3.5 times more than Fumaderm® in Germany (dose-related calculation). This regulatory hurdle has created further complications: new DMF drug developments for psoriasis cannot utilize Tecfidera®'s existing pre-clinical and clinical data, despite sharing the same active substance.

Skilarence®: A New Hope for Psoriasis Patients

Almirall, a Spanish company, developed a DMF-only medication with the galenic properties of Fumaderm®, taking advantage of a temporary EMA allowance for hybrid generics. This paved the way for European approval of DMF therapy for psoriasis. A European comparative study between LAS41008, the new DMF development drug, and Fumaderm® showed no differences in efficacy, tolerability, and adverse drug reactions. This study was the basis for the EMA's positive opinion on April 21, 2017, and the EU approval on June 27, 2017, of LAS41008 under the brand name Skilarence®.

Skilarence®'s dosing and titration schedule are identical to those of Fumaderm®, and it is available in 30 mg and 120 mg DMF tablets. The pharmacological properties also match those of Fumaderm® due to the identical galenic formulation. A key advantage of Skilarence® is the updated monitoring recommendations, which align with clinical practice and guidelines, improving safety. For Skilarence®, monitoring can be done every 3 months if Lymphocytes is above 1000/Microliter. if it goes below this a monthly test must be taken. If Lymphocyte is below 700/Microliter, therapy must stop.

The approval of Skilarence®, containing only DMF, makes approvals outside Europe feasible. However, to further benefit patients, regulatory bodies like the EMA should reconsider their stance on DMF. The EMA should have a clear position for Europe.

About this Article -

This article was crafted using a human-AI hybrid and collaborative approach. AI assisted our team with initial drafting, research insights, identifying key questions, and image generation. Our human editors guided topic selection, defined the angle, structured the content, ensured factual accuracy and relevance, refined the tone, and conducted thorough editing to deliver helpful, high-quality information.See our About page for more information.

This article is based on research published under:

DOI-LINK: 10.1111/ddg.13308, Alternate LINK

Title: Fumarsäureester Werden Europäer

Subject: Dermatology

Journal: JDDG: Journal der Deutschen Dermatologischen Gesellschaft

Publisher: Wiley

Authors: Ulrich Mrowietz

Published: 2017-10-01

Everything You Need To Know

1

How do fumaric acid esters, such as those in Fumaderm®, work to treat psoriasis?

Fumaric acid esters, like those found in Fumaderm®, work by modulating the immune system and reducing inflammation. While the exact mechanism isn't fully understood, it's believed that dimethyl fumarate (DMF), a key component, plays a significant role in this process. However, the original formulation of Fumaderm® also included ethyl hydrogen fumarate salts, the rationale for which remains unknown. This combination was initially approved based on limited data but proved effective in managing psoriasis symptoms for many patients.

2

Why was Fumaderm® initially successful, and what factors limited its wider adoption in Europe?

Fumaderm® initially gained traction due to its effectiveness as a systemic treatment for psoriasis, achieving a substantial market share in Germany. However, its complex mixture of fumaric acid esters, including dimethyl fumarate and ethyl hydrogen fumarate salts, without a clear scientific justification, hindered its broader approval in other European countries. This led to the development of DMF-only formulations like FAG-201 and ultimately, Tecfidera®.

3

What is Tecfidera®, and how does it differ from Fumaderm® in terms of composition, side effects, and approved uses?

Tecfidera® contains only dimethyl fumarate (DMF) and was initially developed as BG-12. While it demonstrated comparable efficacy to Fumaderm®, it featured a new formulation using DMF-containing microtablets in a gastric acid-resistant capsule, resulting in fewer gastrointestinal side effects. Subsequently, Biogen acquired Fumapharm and shifted Tecfidera's focus to multiple sclerosis, leading to its approval by the FDA and EMA for this condition. Ironically, the regulatory bodies classified DMF in Tecfidera® as a "new chemical entity" despite its presence in the older drug, Fumaderm®.

4

What is Skilarence®, and how did it gain approval in Europe for the treatment of psoriasis?

Skilarence® emerged as a DMF-only medication designed to mirror the galenic properties of Fumaderm®. Almirall developed it, capitalizing on a temporary EMA allowance for hybrid generics, paving the way for European approval for treating psoriasis. Comparative studies between Skilarence® and Fumaderm® demonstrated similar efficacy, tolerability, and adverse reaction profiles, leading to its EU approval in 2017. This provides an alternative DMF therapy for psoriasis patients in Europe.

5

What are the implications of classifying dimethyl fumarate (DMF) in Tecfidera® as a 'new chemical entity'?

The decision to classify dimethyl fumarate (DMF) in Tecfidera® as a 'new chemical entity' despite its presence in Fumaderm® has significant regulatory and economic implications. It prevents the direct use of Fumaderm® data for the approval of new DMF drugs targeting psoriasis and creates market dynamics where Tecfidera®, approved for multiple sclerosis, is priced considerably higher than Fumaderm®. This situation creates barriers to entry for new psoriasis treatments based on DMF, despite its proven efficacy, as demonstrated by Skilarence®.

Newsletter Subscribe

Subscribe to get the latest articles and insights directly in your inbox.