Can AI Actually Understand Us? How Language Models are Rewriting Social Science

Lena Voss in Tech & Innovation July 2025 • 4 min read.

"From simulating negotiations to predicting auction outcomes, AI language models are being used to automate and revolutionize the study of social interactions, but can they truly replicate human understanding?"

For decades, social scientists have relied on traditional methods to study human behavior, often constrained by the time-consuming and resource-intensive nature of experiments and data collection. But what if we could automate the process of generating and testing social scientific hypotheses? Recent advances in artificial intelligence, specifically in large language models (LLMs), are making this a reality, opening up exciting new avenues for understanding human interaction.

A groundbreaking new approach uses LLMs, not just as tools for data analysis, but as active participants in simulated social scenarios. Imagine AI-powered agents negotiating deals, attending bail hearings, or even participating in auctions. By using 'structural causal models,' researchers can design these simulations to automatically generate hypotheses, run experiments, and analyze results, all within a digital environment.

This approach presents a radical shift in how social science research is conducted. But the key question remains: can these AI simulations truly replicate the nuances of human behavior, or are they simply generating sophisticated, but ultimately hollow, imitations? This article dives into the promise and potential pitfalls of automated social science, exploring whether AI can genuinely understand us, or if it's just telling us what we want to hear.

Automated Hypothesis Generation: A New Frontier

AI brain collaborating with miniature social scientists.

The core innovation lies in the use of structural causal models (SCMs). These models provide a framework for stating hypotheses in a precise, mathematical language. Think of them as blueprints for constructing AI-based agents and designing experiments. They outline the relationships between different variables, such as a buyer's budget or a seller's emotional attachment to an object, and how these factors might influence an outcome, like whether a deal is made.

The researchers built an open-source computational system that puts this approach into practice. The system can automatically: Generate hypotheses about social interactions, Design experiments to test these hypotheses, Run these experiments using independent LLM-powered agents, Analyze the results to validate or refute the initial hypotheses.

Negotiation Simulations: Two AI agents bargaining over the price of a mug.
Bail Hearing Simulations: An AI judge setting bail for a defendant.
Job Interview Simulations: An AI lawyer interviewing for a job.
Auction Simulations: AI bidders competing for a piece of art.

Interestingly, when the LLM was given its proposed structural causal model for each scenario, it could accurately predict the signs of estimated effects (positive or negative). However, it struggled to reliably predict the magnitudes of those effects. This suggests that while the LLM possesses a general understanding of social dynamics, it lacks the precise calibration needed to make accurate quantitative predictions. In essence, the LLM knows more than it can immediately articulate but is enhanced when it can condition on the fitted structural causal model.

The Future of Social Science: Collaboration Between Humans and AI

Automated social science is not meant to replace traditional research methods. Instead, it offers a powerful new tool for generating hypotheses, exploring complex social dynamics, and accelerating the pace of discovery. By combining the power of AI with the insights of human researchers, we can gain a deeper and more comprehensive understanding of ourselves and the world around us. The key is not to see AI as a replacement for human intellect, but as a partner in the pursuit of knowledge.

About this Article -

This article was crafted using a human-AI hybrid and collaborative approach. AI assisted our team with initial drafting, research insights, identifying key questions, and image generation. Our human editors guided topic selection, defined the angle, structured the content, ensured factual accuracy and relevance, refined the tone, and conducted thorough editing to deliver helpful, high-quality information.See our About page for more information.

Everything You Need To Know

How are AI language models changing the way social science research is conducted?

AI language models are revolutionizing social science by automating the generation and testing of hypotheses. Researchers use these models, along with structural causal models, to simulate social scenarios, design experiments, and analyze results within a digital environment. This allows for quicker exploration of complex social dynamics compared to traditional, more time-consuming methods. However, the ability of these AI simulations to truly replicate the nuances of human behavior is still being explored.

What are structural causal models, and how are they used in automated social science?

Structural causal models (SCMs) provide a mathematical framework for stating hypotheses about social interactions. They act as blueprints for constructing AI-based agents and designing experiments. SCMs outline the relationships between variables, such as a buyer's budget or a seller's emotional attachment, and how these variables influence outcomes, such as whether a deal is made. Researchers use SCMs to design simulations where AI agents interact, allowing them to automatically generate hypotheses, run experiments, and analyze results.

Can AI language models accurately predict human behavior in social situations?

AI language models show promise in understanding the direction of effects in social dynamics, for example if a variable has a positive or negative effect. However, they often struggle with predicting the precise magnitudes of those effects. While these models possess a general understanding of social dynamics, they currently lack the precise calibration needed to make accurate quantitative predictions. Integrating structural causal models enhances the language models capabilities allowing them to make more calibrated estimations.

What are some examples of social scenarios that AI language models are being used to simulate?

AI language models are being used to simulate a variety of social scenarios, including negotiation simulations where two AI agents bargain over the price of a mug. Other examples include bail hearing simulations where an AI judge sets bail for a defendant, job interview simulations where an AI lawyer interviews for a job, and auction simulations where AI bidders compete for a piece of art. These simulations allow researchers to study decision-making processes and social dynamics in a controlled environment.

What is the future role of AI in social science research, and how will it interact with traditional methods?

Automated social science, powered by AI, is not intended to replace traditional research methods. Instead, it offers a new tool for generating hypotheses, exploring complex social dynamics, and accelerating the pace of discovery. The future of social science lies in collaboration between human researchers and AI, combining the power of AI with human insights. AI can serve as a partner in the pursuit of knowledge, allowing researchers to gain a deeper and more comprehensive understanding of human behavior and social interactions.