AI nodes influencing prices

Are Algorithms Secretly Colluding? How AI Recommender Systems Impact Online Prices

Kai Mendoza in Tech & Innovation June 2025 • 4 min read.

"A deep dive into how platforms' recommender systems influence pricing, competition, and consumer welfare in the age of AI."

In the ever-evolving landscape of online commerce, Artificial Intelligence (AI) has become an indispensable tool. AI-powered pricing algorithms now determine the costs of everything from airline tickets to hotel rooms. However, the story doesn't end with just pricing. Online platforms utilize another form of AI which are recommender systems which influence how consumers discover and purchase products.

Recent research suggests that these AI-driven systems aren't always working in the consumer's favor. Algorithmic collusion, where algorithms tacitly agree to set prices higher than competitive levels, is becoming a growing concern. But what role do recommender systems play in this complex dynamic? Are they exacerbating the problem, or could they be part of the solution?

A groundbreaking new study, "Algorithmic Collusion or Competition: the Role of Platforms' Recommender Systems," is shedding light on this critical question. By developing a novel framework that integrates consumer behavior, pricing algorithms, and recommender systems, the research uncovers the hidden ways these systems shape online prices and impact consumer welfare.

The AI Pricing Game: Unveiling How Recommender Systems Tip the Scales

Imagine an online marketplace where sellers use AI to dynamically adjust their prices and it's not based on supply and demand like how it should be. Now imagine that same AI determining your recommendations, and these recommendations are not in your best interest. This study develops a detailed model to simulate this scenario, incorporating key elements:

Consumer Decision-Making: A structural search model that captures how consumers make choices based on varying recommendation sets, considering factors like utility, search costs, and individual preferences. This model uses real-world data to realistically simulate consumer behavior.

Pricing Algorithms: AI algorithms that sellers use to set prices, adapting to market conditions and competitor behavior through reinforcement learning.
Recommender Systems: Algorithms designed to maximize either platform revenue or consumer utility by strategically influencing product visibility.
Repeated Game Framework: A simulation environment where sellers and the platform interact over multiple periods, allowing researchers to observe how pricing dynamics and market outcomes evolve.

By integrating these elements, the researchers created a comprehensive framework to analyze the impact of recommender systems on algorithmic pricing. The simulations revealed some surprising and important insights.

The Future of Fair Pricing: A Call for Transparency and Holistic Regulation

This research provides valuable insights for regulators, platform designers, and market participants. It highlights the need for a more holistic approach to regulating online marketplaces, one that considers the interplay between pricing algorithms and recommender systems. By promoting transparency and aligning the incentives of platforms with consumer welfare, we can ensure a fairer and more competitive online environment for everyone.

About this Article -

This article was crafted using a human-AI hybrid and collaborative approach. AI assisted our team with initial drafting, research insights, identifying key questions, and image generation. Our human editors guided topic selection, defined the angle, structured the content, ensured factual accuracy and relevance, refined the tone, and conducted thorough editing to deliver helpful, high-quality information.See our About page for more information.

Everything You Need To Know

How do AI recommender systems influence online prices?

AI recommender systems impact online prices by influencing product visibility and consumer choices. These systems, designed to maximize platform revenue or consumer utility, strategically affect which products consumers see, thus shaping their purchasing decisions. The study "Algorithmic Collusion or Competition: the Role of Platforms' Recommender Systems" explores how these systems interact with pricing algorithms to influence prices and impact consumer welfare. This involves integrating consumer behavior models, pricing algorithms, and recommender systems to simulate market dynamics and understand their effects.

What is algorithmic collusion and how do recommender systems relate to it?

Algorithmic collusion refers to a situation where algorithms, often used by sellers, tacitly agree to set prices higher than competitive levels. Recommender systems can either exacerbate or mitigate this issue. The research suggests that by influencing product visibility and consumer choices, recommender systems can potentially facilitate collusion or promote competition, depending on how they are designed and the incentives they align with. The study models this through a 'Repeated Game Framework', observing how pricing dynamics evolve over multiple periods when sellers and the platform interact, integrating consumer behavior, pricing algorithms, and recommender systems.

What are the key components of the research framework used to study recommender systems and pricing?

The research framework integrates several key elements: Consumer Decision-Making, which models how consumers make choices based on recommendation sets, considering factors like utility, search costs, and individual preferences using real-world data; Pricing Algorithms, which are AI algorithms used by sellers to set prices, adapting to market conditions and competitor behavior through reinforcement learning; Recommender Systems, which are algorithms designed to maximize platform revenue or consumer utility by strategically influencing product visibility; and a Repeated Game Framework, a simulation environment where sellers and the platform interact over multiple periods to observe pricing dynamics. This comprehensive integration allows researchers to analyze the impact of recommender systems on algorithmic pricing.

How do pricing algorithms work within this context?

In this context, pricing algorithms are AI algorithms that sellers use to dynamically adjust their prices. These algorithms adapt to market conditions and competitor behavior through reinforcement learning. The algorithms are integral to the study's framework and interact with both recommender systems and consumer behavior models. The AI algorithms are designed to set prices, reacting to what competitors do and how consumers respond to these prices and recommendations. This interplay is modeled within a 'Repeated Game Framework' to observe how pricing dynamics evolve.

Why is transparency and holistic regulation important in the context of AI-driven pricing?

Transparency and holistic regulation are crucial to ensure a fairer and more competitive online environment. The research highlights the need for regulators, platform designers, and market participants to consider the interplay between pricing algorithms and recommender systems. By promoting transparency, such as making the function of 'Recommender Systems' more clear, and aligning the incentives of platforms with consumer welfare, we can mitigate the risks of algorithmic collusion and promote more competitive pricing. This approach aims to prevent AI from setting prices that are not in the consumer's best interest.