AI robots playing chess on a cityscape chessboard.

Algorithmic Pricing: Are AI Price Wars Inevitable?

Author's portrait.
Rhea Morgan in Business & Economy May 2025 • 4 min read.

"Discover how AI pricing algorithms can lead to unintended collusion and what it means for consumers and competition policy."


Imagine a world where the prices of everyday items fluctuate not based on supply and demand, but on the silent calculations of artificial intelligence. This isn't science fiction; it's the reality of algorithmic pricing, where companies use AI to set prices in real-time. The rise of these pricing algorithms has sparked both excitement and concern, particularly regarding their potential to mimic collusion, even without any explicit agreement between competitors.

Senator Amy Klobuchar introduced the Preventing Algorithmic Collusion Act. Her statement encapsulates this worry: price fixing, traditionally a human endeavor, might now occur through the automated actions of algorithms. These algorithms, designed to maximize profits, could inadvertently lead to inflated prices for consumers, impacting everything from rent to rideshares.

While regulators and lawmakers grapple with adapting antitrust laws to this new reality, a deeper question emerges: Can algorithms, acting independently, truly create collusive outcomes? Recent research suggests the answer is a resounding yes, challenging the very foundation of competition policy.

When Algorithms Act Like Cartels: Understanding the Dynamics

AI robots playing chess on a cityscape chessboard.

Collusion, traditionally, requires communication, agreement, and the ability to punish those who deviate. Yet, recent economic models demonstrate that algorithmic pricing can generate similar results even when these conditions are absent. In these models, firms use algorithms that adapt to market conditions, learning from each other's pricing strategies and adjusting their own accordingly.

These pricing algorithms often involve a parameterized family of model specifications, meaning they can adapt to different ways of understanding the market. Firms update these parameters and the weights they place on different models to adapt endogenously to market outcomes. The outcome? Markets experience recurrent episodes where firms set prices at levels that resemble collusion.

  • Communication Breakdown: There is no explicit or implicit communication between firms.
  • Agreement-Free Zone: Firms do not need to agree on a target outcome or punishment mechanism.
  • Short-Sighted Strategies: Firms are myopic, focusing only on immediate profits rather than long-term gains.
  • Simple Rules: Algorithms are simple, avoiding complex strategies or historical analysis.
The key to this "algorithmic collusion" lies in the combination of endogenous algorithmic selection and adaptation with an endogenous data generating process. Each firm independently chooses an algorithmic pricing specification that it updates over time. They treat the price process of competing firms as an exogenous factor and adjust to reach the competitive outcome. But as each firm updates its pricing strategy based on independent parameters, they begin to correlate their pricing behaviors.

The Future of Competition in an Algorithmic World

The implications of algorithmic pricing are far-reaching. As AI becomes more sophisticated, the line between independent adaptation and tacit collusion may blur even further, presenting a significant challenge to competition policy. Lawmakers and regulators must consider these new dynamics to ensure fair markets and prevent unintended consequences that harm consumers. This challenge highlights the need for continuous adaptation and vigilance in the face of rapidly evolving technology.

Everything You Need To Know

1

What exactly is algorithmic pricing and why should I care?

Algorithmic pricing refers to the use of artificial intelligence to dynamically set prices, often in real-time. This involves algorithms that analyze various factors to determine the optimal price point. It's significant because it can lead to more efficient pricing strategies for companies but also raises concerns about unintended collusion and inflated prices for consumers. The implications include the need for regulators to adapt competition policies to address these new pricing dynamics.

2

What is algorithmic collusion, and why is it a problem?

Algorithmic collusion is when pricing algorithms, acting independently, lead to similar outcomes as traditional collusion (price fixing) without any explicit agreement between companies. This is important because it challenges the traditional understanding of how collusion occurs and makes it more difficult to detect and prevent. The implications are that current antitrust laws may be insufficient to address this new form of collusion, potentially harming consumers through higher prices.

3

What is the Preventing Algorithmic Collusion Act and what does it aim to do?

The Preventing Algorithmic Collusion Act is proposed legislation aimed at addressing the potential for algorithms to engage in price fixing. It's important because it represents an effort to update antitrust laws to account for the unique challenges posed by AI-driven pricing. The implications of such legislation could include increased scrutiny of algorithmic pricing practices and potential penalties for companies whose algorithms are found to be engaging in collusive behavior.

4

How do algorithms end up acting like cartels, even without companies talking to each other?

The dynamics of algorithmic pricing that mimic cartels involve algorithms that adapt to market conditions and learn from each other's pricing strategies. Key characteristics include the absence of explicit communication or agreement between firms, short-sighted strategies focused on immediate profits, and simple rules governing the algorithms' behavior. The importance lies in understanding how these algorithms can independently arrive at collusive outcomes. The implications are that traditional methods of detecting and preventing collusion may not be effective in this context, requiring new approaches to competition policy.

5

What is endogenous algorithmic selection and adaptation and how does that affect pricing?

Endogenous algorithmic selection and adaptation refers to the process where firms independently choose and update their algorithmic pricing specifications over time, treating the pricing strategies of competing firms as an external factor. The significance of this process is that, despite the independent choices, the algorithms can begin to correlate their pricing behaviors, leading to potential collusion. The implications are that even without explicit coordination, algorithmic pricing can result in markets that resemble cartels, requiring careful monitoring and regulation.

Newsletter Subscribe

Subscribe to get the latest articles and insights directly in your inbox.