Crossroads of decision with floating feedback bubbles.

Sharpen Your Judgment: How Feedback Can Boost Your Decision-Making Skills

Author's portrait.
Nico Varela in Mind & Education August 2025 • 4 min read.

"Unlock the power of outcome and performance feedback to improve your judgment and reduce overconfidence. Discover practical strategies for better decision-making."


In today's fast-paced world, good judgment is more valuable than ever. Whether you're making critical business decisions, managing personal finances, or simply navigating daily life, the ability to assess situations accurately and make sound choices is essential. But what if your judgment is clouded by overconfidence or biases? Research suggests that many of us overestimate the accuracy of our own knowledge and decisions, leading to potentially costly mistakes.

Overconfidence isn't just a personal flaw; it can impact entire organizations. In fields like auditing and finance, where precise judgment is paramount, overconfidence can lead to overlooked risks, missed opportunities, and compromised performance. That's why understanding how to improve judgment and reduce overconfidence is a crucial skill for professionals and individuals alike.

Fortunately, there are proven strategies to enhance your decision-making abilities. One of the most effective methods is feedback. By actively seeking and analyzing feedback on your decisions, you can gain valuable insights into your strengths and weaknesses, identify areas for improvement, and ultimately make better choices. Let's dive into the world of feedback and explore how it can transform your judgment.

The Science of Judgment: Why We Need Feedback

Crossroads of decision with floating feedback bubbles.

Judgment, at its core, is the process of evaluating information and making decisions based on that evaluation. It involves assessing probabilities, weighing risks and benefits, and considering potential outcomes. However, human judgment is far from perfect. Cognitive biases, emotional influences, and simple lack of information can all distort our perceptions and lead to flawed decisions. One of the most common pitfalls is overconfidence, the tendency to overestimate our own abilities and knowledge.

Research consistently demonstrates that people are often overconfident in their judgments. In one study, auditors were found to overestimate the accuracy of their own knowledge, highlighting the prevalence of this bias even among trained professionals. Overconfidence can manifest in various ways, from failing to detect unexpected problems to pursuing unnecessary investigations, both of which can negatively impact efficiency and effectiveness.

  • Overconfidence: Can lead to missed risks and flawed decisions.
  • Under-confidence: Can result in excessive caution and wasted resources.
  • Poor Calibration: Indicates a mismatch between subjective confidence and actual accuracy.
Feedback acts as a corrective mechanism, helping us to identify and address these biases. By receiving information about the outcomes of our decisions and the quality of our performance, we can refine our judgment and improve our accuracy. Feedback comes in two primary forms: outcome feedback and performance feedback.

The Path to Better Decisions: Embracing Feedback

Improving judgment is an ongoing process that requires a commitment to self-reflection and a willingness to learn from experience. By actively seeking and analyzing feedback, we can identify our biases, refine our strategies, and make more informed decisions. Whether you're an auditor, a financial professional, or simply someone who wants to improve your everyday choices, embracing feedback is a powerful step toward better judgment and greater success.

About this Article -

This article was crafted using a human-AI hybrid and collaborative approach. AI assisted our team with initial drafting, research insights, identifying key questions, and image generation. Our human editors guided topic selection, defined the angle, structured the content, ensured factual accuracy and relevance, refined the tone, and conducted thorough editing to deliver helpful, high-quality information.See our About page for more information.

Everything You Need To Know

1

Why is good judgment considered so important in various aspects of life?

Good judgment is crucial because it enables us to accurately assess situations and make sound choices, whether in critical business decisions, personal finance management, or everyday life scenarios. Overconfidence and biases can cloud our judgment, leading to mistakes. Improving judgment through strategies like seeking feedback is essential for better outcomes.

2

How does overconfidence affect professionals in fields like auditing and finance?

In fields like auditing and finance, overconfidence can lead to overlooking risks, missing opportunities, and compromising overall performance. When professionals overestimate the accuracy of their knowledge, they may fail to detect unexpected problems or pursue unnecessary investigations, impacting efficiency and effectiveness.

3

What are the main types of feedback that can help improve decision-making?

The primary types of feedback that are essential for improving decision-making are 'outcome feedback' and 'performance feedback'. Outcome feedback provides information about the results of decisions, while performance feedback evaluates the quality of the decision-making process itself. Using both can refine judgment and improve accuracy.

4

What are the consequences of poor calibration in decision-making, and how does it relate to overconfidence and under-confidence?

Poor calibration indicates a mismatch between subjective confidence and actual accuracy. It's directly related to both overconfidence and under-confidence. Overconfidence leads to missed risks and flawed decisions due to inflated self-assessment, while under-confidence results in excessive caution and wasted resources because of undervalued abilities. Addressing poor calibration requires honest feedback and self-reflection.

5

How can actively seeking and analyzing feedback transform one's judgment, and what does this process involve?

Actively seeking and analyzing feedback enables individuals to identify their biases, refine their strategies, and make more informed decisions. This process involves self-reflection, a willingness to learn from experience, and a commitment to continuous improvement. By embracing both 'outcome feedback' and 'performance feedback', professionals and individuals can enhance their decision-making abilities and achieve greater success. The article doesn't directly cover methods for soliciting constructive criticism or specific frameworks for analyzing feedback data, which are important aspects of fully utilizing feedback for judgment improvement.

Newsletter Subscribe

Subscribe to get the latest articles and insights directly in your inbox.