Surreal illustration of agile safety with software code and construction symbolism.

Agile Safety: How to Build Safety-Critical Systems in a Fast-Moving World

"Discover how safety documentation adapts to agile development, ensuring both speed and safety in creating critical systems."


In today's rapidly evolving technological landscape, Agile methodologies have become increasingly popular for software development. However, when it comes to safety-critical systems—those where failure could result in significant harm or loss—the traditional, heavyweight documentation approaches often clash with Agile's emphasis on flexibility and speed. This creates a challenge: how do we ensure safety without sacrificing the responsiveness and efficiency that Agile promises?

Traditionally, safety-critical systems rely on extensive documentation to meticulously detail every aspect of the system's design, development, and testing. While thorough, this approach can be slow and cumbersome, making it difficult to adapt to changing requirements or incorporate new technologies quickly. Agile methods, on the other hand, prioritize working software over comprehensive documentation, continuous delivery, and close collaboration.

The key to bridging this gap lies in adapting safety documentation to fit within the Agile framework. This means finding ways to create documentation that is lightweight, focused, and integrated directly into the development process. The goal is to improve communication, enhance the safety culture, and maintain—or even improve—the overall safety assurance of the system without slowing down the development team. The question then is, how do you strike the perfect balance between thoroughness and agility to ensure safety in every sprint?

Bridging the Gap: Agile Safety Documentation in Practice

Surreal illustration of agile safety with software code and construction symbolism.

The adaptation of safety documentation within Agile frameworks involves several key strategies designed to maintain rigorous safety standards while embracing flexibility. The core approach centers on introducing specific documentation patterns tailored for Agile environments, such as safety epics, safety stories, and agile safety plans. These components ensure that safety considerations are integral at every stage of development, from initial planning to iterative execution.

One effective method is the use of 'safety epics' to define high-level safety requirements. These are broad objectives crafted collaboratively between users and developers, setting the overarching safety goals for the system. 'Safety stories' then break down these epics into smaller, actionable items that can be addressed within a single sprint. This approach ensures that every development cycle includes specific, manageable tasks related to safety. The integration of Systems-Theoretic Processes Analysis (STPA) enhances these processes, ensuring thorough analysis and risk management throughout the development lifecycle.

To maximize the effectiveness of Agile safety documentation, consider the following points:
  • Focus on Clarity: Ensure that all safety documentation is clear, concise, and easily understandable by all team members.
  • Integrate into Workflow: Incorporate safety tasks directly into the sprint backlog to make them a natural part of the development process.
  • Encourage Collaboration: Foster open communication between developers, safety experts, and stakeholders to address safety concerns proactively.
  • Regular Review: Continuously review and update safety documentation to reflect changes in the system or its environment.
Another innovative approach is the implementation of an 'agile safety plan,' which provides a high-level overview of the safety assurance process. This plan outlines the key activities, responsibilities, and timelines for ensuring safety throughout the project. Unlike traditional safety plans, the agile safety plan is designed to be flexible and adaptable, allowing it to evolve as the project progresses. Continuous updates and collaborative reviews ensure that the safety plan remains relevant and effective.

The Future of Agile Safety

The journey to integrate safety documentation into Agile development is ongoing, but the principles of adaptation, integration, and collaboration provide a solid foundation. By embracing these strategies, organizations can build safety-critical systems that are not only robust and reliable but also responsive to change and innovative in their design. The key is to view safety as an integral part of the development process, rather than an afterthought, ensuring that safety and agility can coexist harmoniously.

About this Article -

This article was crafted using a human-AI hybrid and collaborative approach. AI assisted our team with initial drafting, research insights, identifying key questions, and image generation. Our human editors guided topic selection, defined the angle, structured the content, ensured factual accuracy and relevance, refined the tone, and conducted thorough editing to deliver helpful, high-quality information.See our About page for more information.

This article is based on research published under:

DOI-LINK: 10.1145/3120459.3120482, Alternate LINK

Title: A Study Of Safety Documentation In A Scrum Development Process

Journal: Proceedings of the XP2017 Scientific Workshops

Publisher: ACM

Authors: Yang Wang, Ivan Bogicevic, Stefan Wagner

Published: 2017-05-22

Everything You Need To Know

1

What does "Agile safety" mean in the context of developing safety-critical systems, and how does it differ from traditional approaches?

Agile safety adapts safety documentation to fit within the Agile framework. It focuses on creating documentation that is lightweight and integrated directly into the development process. This improves communication, enhances safety culture, and maintains overall safety assurance without slowing down the development team. This includes safety epics, safety stories, and agile safety plans to integrate safety considerations into every stage of the development.

2

What are "safety epics" and "safety stories," and how do they contribute to integrating safety considerations into Agile development sprints?

Safety epics define high-level safety requirements collaboratively between users and developers. They set the overarching safety goals for a system. Safety stories break down these epics into smaller, actionable items that can be addressed within a single sprint. This approach ensures every development cycle includes manageable tasks related to safety. The use of Systems-Theoretic Processes Analysis (STPA) enhances these processes, ensuring thorough analysis and risk management throughout the development lifecycle.

3

How does an "agile safety plan" differ from a traditional safety plan, and what makes it more suitable for fast-paced Agile projects?

An agile safety plan provides a high-level overview of the safety assurance process. It outlines key activities, responsibilities, and timelines for ensuring safety throughout the project. Unlike traditional safety plans, it is designed to be flexible and adaptable, evolving as the project progresses. Continuous updates and collaborative reviews ensure the safety plan remains relevant and effective. A traditional safety plan is slow and cumbersome, making it difficult to adapt to changing requirements or incorporate new technologies quickly.

4

What are some best practices for implementing Agile safety documentation to ensure it is effective and well-integrated into the development workflow?

To maximize effectiveness, safety documentation should be clear, concise, and easily understandable by all team members. Integrate safety tasks directly into the sprint backlog to make them a natural part of the development process. Foster open communication between developers, safety experts, and stakeholders to address safety concerns proactively. Documentation should be reviewed and updated to reflect changes in the system or its environment.

5

What are the key challenges in using Agile methodologies for safety-critical systems, and how does "Agile safety" help address these challenges?

Agile methodologies prioritize working software over comprehensive documentation, continuous delivery, and close collaboration. However, safety-critical systems traditionally rely on extensive documentation to meticulously detail every aspect of the system's design, development, and testing which can be slow and difficult to adapt to. Agile safety bridges this gap by adapting documentation to fit within the Agile framework, focusing on lightweight, integrated documentation to improve communication, enhance safety culture, and maintain safety assurance.

Newsletter Subscribe

Subscribe to get the latest articles and insights directly in your inbox.